

home
| art & architecture | books & cds | dance
| destinations | film | opera | television | theater | archives
Broke

|
|
It is difficult to criticize a group like this, for
multiple reasons. Firstly, critics are easily dismissed as unrepresentative of the group's
actual audience, who are likely considerably less discriminating in their reactions to the
product offered. Secondly, critiques of the group's "message" can be deflected
with the bemused smirk that the critic is "over-reacting" - that this is, at
bottom, a pop-culture excretion like a thousand others, and to single it out for
vituperation grants it too much gravitas. Finally (this being a corollary to the first), a
critic can simply be dismissed as a cranky old prude, attempting to retain some (largely
imagined, both in the minds of promoters and detractors) "traditional American
values" in the face of an advancing culture. For these reasons, and likely more,
criticism of rock music must, to hold any validity at all, be centered around, if not
limited to, the music.
This record can be summed up by the name of its label: jive. It's a
watery attempt to capitalize on a sound currently ruling the adolescent hard rock/metal
audience. Hard rock and metal audiences are deeply riven of late by the addition of
hip-hop influences to what has been a fairly structured - and fairly aesthetically
successful - formula thus far. It amounts to an age divide; those under twenty-five seem
to have a profound affection for rapping, heavily tattooed white biker-types, while those
old enough to remember a metal without such genre-busting touches pine for days gone by.
(Hed) PE are one of the worst acts currently mining the rap-metal
ditch. Their music bears little resemblance to prior notions of metal, or even of
songcraft. The grinding, overamped guitar riffs come as staccato, repetitive blows to the
head, like a pile-driver, only not as pleasant. The drums compete with a scratching DJ to
create a general sense of rhythm, without the sensory pleasures an actual beat might
provide. And the vocals coruscate the listener over the top of this sonic soup, offering
no message beyond an endless stream of curses and vague intimations of mob violence. (In
contemporary hard rock, as in much of the rap absorbed by the same white, suburban
fan-base, mob violence is accepted as a fitting display of group unity.)
This is a bad record. It conforms to current trends, though, and
however transparent that market-pandering may be, a certain number of listeners will still
wind up buying the thing. Too bad for them.
-